« Quarters From Kids on MTV's TRL | Main | "The Debt Relief Summit" »
February 3, 2005
ThinkProgress.org: Rushing to Pull the Race Card
Many thanks to Benchley for hipping me to this blog. Think Progress is a relatively new blog that "seeks to provide a forum that advances progressive ideas and policies." Warning: Those with a right-wing perspective might find the views of Think Progress offensive.
With that being said, I thought a post on Donovan McNabb and Rush Limbaugh was rather interesting; especially in the context of Black History Month. If you got a chance to see the PBS documentary, "Unforgivable Blackness", you would have learned that there was a time when "whites" considered themselves athletically superior to all other races; and we're not just talking about Hitler's Aryan agenda. Jack Johnson, the heavy weight champion of the world at the time, and African-American, challenged this notion with every victory. Flash-forward sixty years and the idea of a black quarterback in the Super Bowl was considerd a BIG deal. The prevailing thought at the time was that black athletes were not intelligent enough to handle this "highly-skilled" position. When faced with challengers to this misguided view (e.g. Doug Williams, eventual Super Bowl MVP), "journalist" searched for an explanation.
I remember CBS commentator, Jimmy the Greek arguing that African-Americans were athletically superior to whites stating that this "fact" was the result of 'selective breeding' -- a biproduct of slavery. Jimmy was promptly fired but make no mistake that his views were generally accepted by a significant percentage of the sports viewing population.
Flash-forward another fifteen or so years and Rush Limbaugh attempts to argue that political correctness is to blame for the perceived success of black quarterbacks like Donovan McNabb. The result: Limbaugh resigned over his statement and McNabb and his team are now poised to unseat the defending Super Bowl champions.
So what do we make of this? If we use athletics as a lens to view history, history has shown us that progress has been made in the area of race-relations. Probably not enough but some. As an African-Canadian, I'm certainly proud of the accomplishments of black athletes such as Donovan McNabb, although to be honest, I don't really think of Donovan's accomplishments in the context of race. It is a testament to our progress as a society that our general reaction to overtly racist comments by the media is to denounce them. With that being said, I worry about the subtle racism that still pervades athletics and the media. What's that you ask? Well, as you watch the Super Bowl this Sunday, pay particular attention to the descriptions made of both MVP-calibre quarterbacks. Undoubtedly, McNabb will be hailed for his athleticism whereas Tom Brady (a white quarterback) will be hailed for his leadership and "good decision-making". A subtle but powerful distinction. Maybe we haven't come that far at all.
Posted by Jason at February 3, 2005 10:42 AM
Comments
Well written!!
Posted by: Benchley at February 5, 2005 5:09 PM
